For a free, no obligation consultation,
call Seelig Law Offices at 212-766-0600 today.

How Much Does Long Term Disability Pay?

How Much Does Long Term Disability Pay?

How much does long term disability pay? Most group long term disability policies replace 50 to 70 percent of pre-disability earnings, often 60 percent, up to a monthly cap. The insurer then subtracts other income, such as Social Security disability, so the actual check is often smaller.

Need legal assistance?

Call us at (212) 766-0600 24/7 to arrange to speak with a lawyer about your case, or contact us through the website today.

Long term disability insurance, often called LTD, pays part of your income when an illness or injury keeps you from working for months or years. Most New Yorkers get it through an employer plan. Others buy an individual disability policy on their own, which is common among doctors, dentists, lawyers, and business owners.

For workers in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island, the policy wording decides the dollar amount, not a state formula. Below, our NYC long term disability attorneys explain how insurers calculate the benefit, what they subtract, and how to check the math. For more on how these claims are handled, see the short and long term disability insurance claims page.

What Percentage of Your Salary Does Long Term Disability Pay?

Group long term disability usually pays 50, 60, or 66 2/3 percent of your monthly earnings before you became disabled. The exact percentage is in your policy or the summary plan description. Every policy also sets a maximum monthly benefit, so high earners often receive far less than the stated percentage.

The summary plan description is the plain-language booklet your employer must provide for an employer plan. Ask human resources or the insurer for it, along with the full policy. The booklet is a summary, so the policy usually controls when the two differ.

Four policy terms set the size of your benefit:

  • Benefit percentage: the share of earnings replaced, such as 60 percent.
  • Covered earnings: the pay the insurer counts. Many group policies count base salary only and leave out bonuses, commissions, and overtime.
  • Maximum monthly benefit: the cap, which varies widely by employer and plan.
  • Minimum monthly benefit: a floor, often $100 or 10 percent of the gross benefit, paid even after offsets.

The covered earnings definition matters most for people paid largely in commissions or bonuses. A salesperson with a modest base salary can end up with a small benefit compared with what they actually earned. Check whether your policy uses the prior year’s W-2 earnings or base pay on the date you stopped working.

How Is a Long Term Disability Benefit Calculated?

Insurers start with the gross benefit, which is the benefit percentage times your covered monthly earnings, capped at the policy maximum. They then subtract other income benefits the policy lists, such as Social Security disability. What remains is your net monthly benefit, but never less than the policy minimum.

Here is a simple example. The numbers are illustrations, not a prediction for any claim:

  • Covered earnings: $90,000 a year, or $7,500 a month
  • Gross benefit at 60 percent: $4,500 a month, under a $10,000 policy cap
  • Social Security disability award: $2,600 a month
  • Net long term disability benefit: $4,500 minus $2,600, or $1,900 a month

Your total income in that example stays at $4,500 a month. The Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) payment simply replaces part of what the insurer was paying. That is why insurers often require you to apply for SSDI and may even help you file.

What Income Can a Long Term Disability Insurer Subtract?

Group policies commonly subtract Social Security disability, workers’ compensation, New York State short term disability, some pension disability benefits, and other group insurance. These subtractions are called offsets. The policy section titled “other income benefits” or “deductible sources of income” lists exactly what your insurer can take.

Common offsets in group policies include:

  • SSDI paid to you, and often SSDI paid to your spouse or children because of your disability
  • Workers’ compensation payments, including some lump-sum settlements spread over time
  • New York State short term disability benefits and other state disability programs
  • Disability retirement or pension benefits, including some civil service disability pensions
  • Wages or sick pay from your employer while you are out

Some policies freeze the SSDI offset at the first award amount, so later Social Security cost-of-living increases do not lower the check. Others are worded differently. If your benefit drops after a COLA or new award, ask the insurer in writing for the calculation and policy language it used.

What Happens to Long Term Disability Pay While SSDI Is Pending?

Many insurers pay the full gross benefit while an SSDI claim is pending, if you sign a reimbursement agreement. If the Social Security Administration later awards back pay for the same months, the insurer can ask for that overlap back. Some insurers instead reduce your benefit right away by an estimated SSDI amount.

An SSDI back pay award can cover many months. When it arrives, the insurer may send a repayment demand for thousands of dollars. Set aside the back pay until you know what the policy lets the insurer recover.

Check the repayment math closely. Attorney fees paid out of the SSDI back pay may reduce what you owe, depending on the policy. Our posts on SSDI back pay and how long it takes to get SSDI in New York explain the Social Security side.

Is Long Term Disability Pay Taxable?

Long term disability pay is taxable when your employer paid the premiums or you paid them with pre-tax dollars. It is generally not taxable when you paid the premiums yourself with after-tax money. When the cost was shared, part of each payment may be taxable, based on who paid what share.

This tax rule changes the real value of a benefit. A $4,000 monthly benefit from a fully employer-paid plan is worth less after taxes than $4,000 from a policy you paid for yourself. Ask your employer how premiums were paid, and check your pay stubs from before you stopped working.

Individual disability policies bought with your own after-tax money usually pay tax-free benefits. That is one reason professionals in New York often buy them on top of group coverage.

How Long Does Long Term Disability Pay Last?

Long term disability usually starts after a 90-day or 180-day elimination period and can last until age 65 or full retirement age. Many policies change the definition of disability after 24 months. Many also limit mental health and self-reported conditions to 24 months of benefits.

The elimination period is the waiting time before benefits begin, often covered by short term disability. Key time limits to look for in your policy:

  • Own occupation period: often 24 months, when you only need to show you cannot do your own job.
  • Any occupation period: after that, you must show you cannot do any job that fits your education, training, and experience, often at a set wage level.
  • Mental nervous limitation: a cap, often 24 months, on benefits for conditions like depression, anxiety, or bipolar disorder.
  • Self-reported symptoms limitation: a cap on conditions diagnosed mainly through symptoms, such as some pain or fatigue conditions.
  • Maximum benefit period: the end date, often age 65 or full retirement age.

The change from own occupation to any occupation is one of the most common points where insurers end benefits. For condition-specific questions, read What medical conditions qualify for long term disability?

Can You Work Part Time and Still Get Long Term Disability Pay?

Often, yes. Many policies pay a partial or residual benefit when you can work part time but earn less because of your condition. The insurer usually reduces the benefit by part of your earnings, and some policies let you keep more during the first months back at work.

Residual disability means you can still work but have lost a set share of your earnings, often 20 percent or more. A return-to-work incentive may let your earnings plus benefits reach your old income for a limited time. Report all work to the insurer, because unreported earnings lead to overpayment demands. Read more in Can you get partial disability and still work?

How Does Long Term Disability Pay Compare With New York Short Term Disability and SSDI?

New York State short term disability pays half your average weekly wage, up to $170 a week, for up to 26 weeks off the job. SSDI pays a monthly amount based on your lifetime Social Security earnings. Long term disability pays a share of recent salary under your policy terms.

The three programs often stack in order. New York State short term disability, paid through employer insurers, covers the first weeks. Long term disability starts after the elimination period. SSDI, once approved, is payable after a five-month waiting period from the date disability began.

The Social Security Administration estimates the average SSDI payment for a disabled worker will be $1,701 a month in January 2027. New York’s $170 weekly short term disability cap has not changed since 1989. For more, read How does short term disability work in New York?

How Do Individual Disability Policies Pay Differently?

Individual disability income policies usually pay a fixed monthly amount stated in the policy, not a percentage of salary. Many do not subtract SSDI or other benefits. They often define disability by your own occupation, which matters for doctors, dentists, lawyers, and other professionals in New York City.

Look for riders, which are add-ons that change the benefit. A cost-of-living rider raises payments over time during a long claim. A residual rider pays when you return to work at reduced income. A social insurance rider pays an extra amount only until SSDI or another public benefit starts.

Insurers sometimes dispute individual claims by questioning your occupation’s duties or your income records. Keep tax returns, practice records, and a written description of your actual daily duties before the disability began.

What Should You Do If the Insurer Pays Less Than the Policy Promises?

Ask the insurer in writing for the benefit calculation, the full policy, and your claim file. Compare the earnings figure, percentage, cap, and each offset with the policy. Employer plans governed by federal employee benefits law must generally give you at least 180 days to appeal a denial or adverse decision.

The administrative appeal is often your only chance to add evidence. In a later federal lawsuit over an employer plan, the court usually reviews only the administrative record. The administrative record is the set of documents the insurer had when it made its final decision.

Useful items to gather for a benefit dispute include pay stubs, W-2s, commission and bonus records, the summary plan description, and every offset letter. For denials under employer plans, see our employer plan disability claim denial page.

How Do Our NYC Long Term Disability Attorneys Handle Benefit Amount Disputes?

Our NYC long term disability attorneys start by checking the insurer’s math against the policy. That means confirming covered earnings, the cap, and every offset. From there, the work follows the claim through the administrative appeal and, where it applies, a lawsuit in federal court.

  • Policy review: obtaining the full policy, summary plan description, and claim file.
  • Earnings review: checking whether bonuses, commissions, or other pay should count.
  • Offset review: checking SSDI, workers’ compensation, and pension offsets, including repayment demands.
  • Appeal: building the administrative record with medical records, treating doctor opinions, and vocational evidence.
  • Coordination: handling the SSDI claim alongside the long term disability claim so the two fit together.

Long term disability matters are often handled on contingency or a hybrid arrangement, depending on the matter. Questions about how much your long term disability should pay? Contact Seelig Law Group to talk with our New York City disability team.

Need legal assistance?

Call us at (212) 766-0600 24/7 to arrange to speak with a lawyer about your case, or contact us through the website today.

Sources

Recent Posts

Archives

Categories

For Representation From Attorneys Dedicated To Providing The Highest Quality Representation To Clients, Contact Seelig Law Offices Today.

© 2026 Seelig Law Offices • All rights reserved.